What Is Convergence Theory?

How Convergence Affects Developing Nations

Symbolizes of capitalism in China, including McDonald's and Pepsi, show convergence theory in action.
Symbols of capitalism in formerly communist China, including McDonald's and Pepsi, show convergence theory in action. Danny Lehman/Getty Images

Convergence theory presumes that as nations move from the early stages of industrialization toward becoming fully industrialized, they begin to resemble other industrialized societies in terms of societal norms and technology. The characteristics of these nations effectively converge. Eventually and ultimately, this could lead to a unified global culture, if nothing impeded the process.

Convergence theory has its roots in the functionalist perspective of economics which assumes that societies have certain requirements that must be met if they are to survive and operate effectively.

 

The History of Convergence Theory 

Convergence theory became popular in the 1960s when it was formulated by the University of California, Berkeley Professor of Economics Clark Kerr. Some theorists have since expounded upon Kerr's original premise with the opinion that industrialized nations may become more alike in some ways than in others. Convergence theory is not an across-the-board transformation because although technologies may be shared, it's not as likely that more fundamental aspects of life such as religion and politics would necessarily converge, though they may. 

Convergence vs. Divergence

Convergence theory is also sometimes referred to as the "catch-up effect." When technology is introduced to nations still in the early stages of industrialization, money from other nations may pour in to develop and take advantage of this opportunity. These nations may become more accessible and susceptible to international markets.

This allows them to "catch up" with more advanced nations.

If capital is not invested in these countries, however, and if international markets do not take notice or find that opportunity is viable there, no catch-up can occur. The country is then said to have diverged rather than converged. Unstable nations are more likely to diverge because they are unable to converge due to political or social-structural factors, like lack of educational or job-training resources.

Convergence theory, therefore, would not apply to them. 

Convergence theory also allows that the economies of developing nations will grow more rapidly than those of industrialized countries under these circumstances. Therefore, all should reach an equal footing eventually.

Examples of Convergence Theory 

Some examples of convergence theory include Russia and Vietnam, formerly purely communist countries that have eased away from strict communist doctrines as the economies in other countries, such as the US, have burgeoned. State-controlled socialism is less the norm in these countries now than is market socialism, which allows for economic fluctuations and, in some cases, private businesses as well. Russia and Vietnam have both experienced economic growth as their socialistic rules and politics have changed and relaxed to some degree.

European Axis nations including Italy, Germany, and Japan rebuilt their economic bases after World War II into economies not dissimilar to those that existed among the Allied Powers of the United States, the Soviet Union, and Great Britain.

More recently, in the mid-20th century, some East Asian countries converged with other more developed nations. Singapore, South Korea, and Taiwan are now all considered to be developed, industrialized nations.

Sociological Critiques of Convergence Theory

Convergence theory is an economic theory that presupposes that the concept of development is 1. a universally good thing, and 2. defined by economic growth. It frames convergence with supposedly "developed" nations to as a goal of so-called "undeveloped" or "developing" nations, and in doing so, fails to account for the numerous negative outcomes that often follow this economically-focused model of development.

Many sociologists, postcolonial scholars, and environmental scientists have observed that this type of development often only further enriches the already wealthy, and/or creates or expands a middle class while exacerbating the poverty and poor quality of life experienced by the majority of the nation in question. Additionally, it is a form of development that typically relies on the over-use of natural resources, displaces subsistence and small-scale agriculture, and causes widespread pollution and damage to the natural habitat.

Updated by Nicki Lisa Cole, Ph.D.

Format
mla apa chicago
Your Citation
Crossman, Ashley. "What Is Convergence Theory?" ThoughtCo, Aug. 10, 2017, thoughtco.com/convergence-theory-3026158. Crossman, Ashley. (2017, August 10). What Is Convergence Theory? Retrieved from https://www.thoughtco.com/convergence-theory-3026158 Crossman, Ashley. "What Is Convergence Theory?" ThoughtCo. https://www.thoughtco.com/convergence-theory-3026158 (accessed January 20, 2018).