Economics as the "Dismal Science"

Thomas Carlyle
Biblioteca Ambrosiana/De Agostini Picture Library/Getty Images

If you've ever studied economics, you've probably heard at some point that economics is referred to as the "dismal science." Granted, economists aren't always the most upbeat bunch of people, but is that really why the phrase came about?

Origin of the Phrase "Dismal Science" to Describe Economics

As it turns out, the phrase has been around since the mid-19th century, and it was coined by historian Thomas Carlyle. At the time, the skills required for writing poetry were referred to as the "gay science," so Carlyle decided to call economics the "dismal science" as a clever turn of phrase.

The popular belief is that Carlyle started using the phrase in response to the "dismal" prediction of 19th-century reverend and scholar Thomas Malthus, who forecasted that the rate of growth in the food supply as compared to the rate of the growth in population would result in mass starvation. (Luckily for us, Malthus' assumptions regarding technological progress were overly, well, dismal, and such mass starvation never transpired.)

While Carlyle did use the word dismal in reference to Malthus' findings, he didn't use the phrase "dismal science" until his 1849 work Occasional Discourse on the Negro Question. In this piece, Carlyle argued that reintroducing (or continuing) the enslavement of Black people would be morally superior to relying on the market forces of supply and demand, and he labeled the profession of economists who disagreed with him, most notably John Stuart Mill, as the "dismal science," since Carlyle believed that the emancipation of enslaved people would leave them worse off. (This prediction has also turned out to be incorrect, of course.)

mla apa chicago
Your Citation
Beggs, Jodi. "Economics as the "Dismal Science"." ThoughtCo, Feb. 16, 2021, Beggs, Jodi. (2021, February 16). Economics as the "Dismal Science". Retrieved from Beggs, Jodi. "Economics as the "Dismal Science"." ThoughtCo. (accessed March 21, 2023).