Ma or Myr? How We Talk About Geologic Time

fossils
davida3/Flickr/CC BY-ND 2.0

Geologists have a bit of awkwardness in their language in talking about the deep past: distinguishing dates from durations. We don't have a problem with the weirdness of historical time--in 2012, we can easily say that an event in 200 BCE happened 2211 years ago and that an object made back then is 2211 years old today. (Remember, there was no year 0.)

Among geologists, a widespread practice has arisen in the last few decades that gives dates (not ages) in the format "X Ma"; for example, rocks that formed 5 million years ago are said to date from 5 Ma.

"5 Ma" is a point in time that is 5 million years from the present. Instead of saying that the rock is "5 Ma old," geologists use a different abbreviation like m.y., mya, myr, or Myr. This is a little awkward, but the context makes things clear.

Agreeing on a Definition for Ma

Recently the International Union of Pure and Applied Chemistry (IUPAC) and the International Union of Geological Sciences (IUGS) convened a task force to decide on an official definition of the year to go into the Système International or SI, the "metric system." The exact definition isn't important here, but the symbol they chose, "a," would happen to override geological custom by requiring everyone to use "Ma" (and ka and Ga, etc.) everywhere. That would make writing geology papers somewhat harder, but we could adjust.

But Nicholas Christie-Blick of Columbia University has looked more deeply at the proposal and cries foul in GSA Today.

He raises an important question: How can SI accommodate the year as a "derived unit" when SI rules require that these must be simple powers of base units? There's no room in the rules for a derived unit called the year, which would be defined as 31,556,925.445 s. Derived units are things like the gram (10-3 kilogram).

If this were a legal dispute, Christie-Blick would be arguing that the year has no standing.

"Start over," he says, and get buy-in from geologists."

Format
mla apa chicago
Your Citation
Alden, Andrew. "Ma or Myr? How We Talk About Geologic Time." ThoughtCo, Mar. 27, 2017, thoughtco.com/how-we-talk-about-geologic-time-3974394. Alden, Andrew. (2017, March 27). Ma or Myr? How We Talk About Geologic Time. Retrieved from https://www.thoughtco.com/how-we-talk-about-geologic-time-3974394 Alden, Andrew. "Ma or Myr? How We Talk About Geologic Time." ThoughtCo. https://www.thoughtco.com/how-we-talk-about-geologic-time-3974394 (accessed January 23, 2018).