Nietzsche's Concept Of The Will To Power

One of his most basic but most easily misunderstood ideas

Nietzsche. Hulton Archive/Getty Images

The “will to power” is a central concept in the philosophy of  the19th century German philosopher Friedrich Nietzsche.  But what, exactly, does he mean by the will to power?

Origins of the idea

In his early twenties Nietzsche read The World as Will and Representation by Arthur Schopenhauer (1788-1860) and fell under its spell.  Schopenhauer offered a deeply pessimistic vision of life, and at the heart of it was his idea that a blind, ceaselessly striving, irrational force he called “Will” constituted the dynamic essence of the world.

  This cosmic Will manifests or expresses itself through each individual in the form of the sexual drive and the “will to life” that can be seen throughout nature.  It is the source of much misery, since it is essentially insatiable.  The best thing one can do to reduce one’s suffering is find ways to calm it.  This is one of the functions of art.

In his first book, The Birth of Tragedy, Nietzsche posits what he calls a “Dionysian” impulse as the source of Greek tragedy.  Like Schopenhauer’s Will, it is an irrational, force that surges up from dark origins, and it expresses itself in wild drunken frenzies, sexual abandon, and festivals of cruelty.  His later notion of the will to power is significantly different; but it retains something of this idea of a deep, pre-rational, unconscious force that can be harnessed and transformed in order to create something beautiful.

The will to power as a psychological principle

In early works like Human All Too Human and Daybreak, Nietzsche devotes a lot of attention to psychology.

  He doesn’t talk explicitly about a “will to power,” but time and again he explains aspects of human behavior in terms of a desire for domination or mastery, over others, self, or environment. In The Gay Science (1882) he begins to be more explicit, and in Thus Spoke Zarathustra begins to use the expression “will to power.”

People unacquainted with Nietzsche’s writings may be inclined to interpret the idea of the will to power rather crudely.  But Nietzsche is not thinking only or even primarily of the motivations behind people like Napoleon or Hitler who expressly seek military and political power.  In fact, he typically applies the theory quite subtly.

For instance, aphorism 13 of The Gay Science is entitled “The theory of the sense of power.”  Here Nietzsche argues that we exercise power over other people both by benefiting them and by hurting them.  When we hurt hem we make them feel out power in a crude way, and also a dangerous way since they may seek to revenge themselves.  Making someone indebted to us usually a preferable way to feel a sense of our power; we also thereby extend our power, since those we benefit see the advantage of being on our side. Nietzsche in fact argues that causing pain is generally less pleasant than showing kindness, and is in fact a sign that one lacks power since it is the inferior option. 

The will to power and Nietzsche’s value judgments

The will to power as Nietzsche conceives of it is neither good nor bad.  It is a basic drive found in everyone, but one that expresses itself in many different ways.

  The philosopher and scientist direct their will to power into a will to truth. Artists channel it into a will to create.  Businessmen satisfy it through becoming rich. 

In On the Genealogy of Morals (1887), Nietzsche contrasts “master morality” and “slave morality,” but traces both back to the will to power.  Creating tables of values, imposing them people, and judging the world according to them, is one noteworthy expression of will to power.  And this idea underlies Nietzsche attempt to understand and evaluate moral systems.  The strong, healthy, masterly type confidently impose their values on the world directly.  The weak, by contrast, seek to impose their values in a more cunning, roundabout way, by making the strong individuals feel guilty about their health, strength, egotism, and pride in themselves.

 

So while the will to power in itself is neither good nor bad, Nietzsche very clearly prefers some ways in which it expresses itself to others.  He doesn’t advocate the pursuit of power.  Rather, he praises the sublimation of the will to power into creativity activity.  Roughly speaking, he praises those expressions of it he views as creative, beautiful and life-affirming, and he criticizes expressions of will to power that he sees as ugly or born of weakness. 

One particular form of the will to power that Nietzsche devotes a lot of attention to is what he calls “self-overcoming.”  Here the will to power is harnessed and directed toward self-mastery and self-transformation, guided by the principle that, “your real self lies not deep within you but high above you.”  Presumably the "Übermensch" or "Superman" that Zarathustra speaks of would be capable of this to the highest degree.

Nietzsche and Darwin

In the 1880s  Nietzsche read and seems to have been influenced by several German theorists who criticized Darwin’s account of how evolution occurs.  In several places he opposes contrasts the will to power with the “will to survive,” which he seems to think is the basis for Darwinism.  In fact, though, Darwin does not posit a will to survive.  Rather, he explains how species evolve due to natural selection in the struggle to survive. 

The will to power as a biological principle

At times Nietzsche seems to posit he will to power as more than just a principle that yields insight into the deep psychological motivations of human beings.  For instance, he has Zarathustra say: “Wherever I found a living thing, I found there the will to power.”  Here the will to power is applied to the biological realm.  And in a fairly straightforward sense, one might understand a simple event such as a big fish eating a little fish as a form of the will to power; the big fish is assimilating part of its environment to itself.

The will to power as a metaphysical principle

Nietzsche contemplated a book entitled “The Will to Power” but never published a book under this name.

  After his death, however, his sister Elizabeth published a collection of unpublished notes, organized and edited by herself, entitled The Will to Power.  Some sections of this make it clear that Nietzsche took seriously the idea that the will to power might be posited as a fundamental principle to be found operating throughout the cosmos.  Section 1067, the last section of the book, and one whose style is clearly quite polished, sums up Nietzsche’s way of thinking about the world as “a monster of energy, without beginning, without end….my Dionysian world of the eternally self-creating, the eternally self-destroying….” And concludes:

“Do you want a name for this world? A solution for all its riddles?  A light for you, too, you best –concealed, strongest, most intrepid, most midnightly men?––This world is the will to power––and nothing besides!  And you yourselves are also this will to power––and nothing besides!”

Related links

Nietzsche's idea of the eternal recurrence

Nietzsche and the Nazis