The Oldest Wooden Schoolhouse, St. Augustine, Florida

of 04

Saint Augustine's Historic Wooden School

Detail of Wooden Shutters on the Oldest Wooden Schoolhouse, St. Augustine, FL
Detail of Wooden Shutters on the Oldest Wooden Schoolhouse, St. Augustine, FL. Photo by Charles Cook/Lonely Planet Images Collection/Getty Images (cropped)

The schoolhouse was one of the first buildings constructed by the settlers of the United States. And if the oldest town in the US is up for debate, so is the oldest schoolhouse. St. Augustine, Florida wants to be the oldest of all.

Most of the original wood construction from Colonial times has gone up in smoke. Fires devastated many historic buildings throughout America, including most of Chicago in the Great Fire of 1871—remember the story about Mrs. O'Leary's Cow? The Great Fire of June 6, 1889 destroyed most of the original settlement architecture of Seattle, Washington. Every urban area has had its problems with fire. Poor St. Augustine must have had its share of fires, too. None of the original wooden structures remain, except one.

The schoolhouse in St. Augustine is thought to have survived since the early 18th century—its pest-resistant red cedar and cypress timbers, put together with wooden pegs and handmade nails, have outlasted the construction of its neighbors.  Drinking water was drawn from a well, and a privy was dug away from the main building. To protect the house from heat and fire dangers, the kitchen was located in separate quarters, detached from the main building. Perhaps that is what has saved the building. Perhaps it's just lucky.

No one knows for sure whether or not the St. Augustine structure is the oldest wooden schoolhouse. New Mexico and other parts of the American West claim to have schools much older. Nevertheless, the St. Augustine Schoolhouse offers some insights into how North American buildings were constructed back in the 1700s.

The building even has its own anchor. What? Read on.

of 04

America's Oldest Schoolhouse Today

Front of oldest school in US and detail of the entrance
Front of oldest school in US and detail of the entrance. Photos (c) Jackie Craven

At first glance, this ramshackle building near St. Augustine's historic city gates may look like a movie set. Surely no house could be that weathered and still stand! But records suggest that the tiny house may be the oldest surviving wooden school building in the United States.

The house must have been constructed before it first appeared on the local 1716 tax rolls. And a Spanish map from 1788 noted that the building was only "in fair condition." Yet it still stood.

It's thought that the Saint Augustine Schoolhouse was originally a small homestead belonging to Juan Genoply. After Genoply married, he added on and eventually the house became a school. The schoolmaster lived upstairs with his family and used the first floor as a classroom. Boys and girls shared the same classroom, making the St. Augustine school one of the first in the young nation to go "co-ed," although it likely was not racially integrated.

Today, the schoolhouse resembles a theme park attraction. Mechanized figures dressed in 18th century attire greet visitors and describe a typical school day. Children can receive make-believe diplomas. But America's "oldest wooden schoolhouse" is not all fun and games. The building has seen very little changes in the past three hundred years.

By examining its construction, you can see how buildings were made in America's colonies. Although it might have an architectural style similar to the log cabins found in America's frontier, this St. Augustine landmark has a facade of rough hewn timber. The style is more Colonial New England than Spanish Colonial typically found on the east coast of Florida.

But what about that anchor? Read on.

of 04

Colonial Construction in St. Augustine

An Anchor Holds Down the Oldest Wood Schoolhouse in the US, St. Augustine, Florida
An Anchor Holds Down the Oldest Wood Schoolhouse in the US, St. Augustine, Florida. Photo by Charles Cook/Lonely Planet Images Collection/Getty Images

If you look closely, you may notice an enormous anchor secured to the house with a long chain. These are not a part of the original construction. Worried that a hurricane might whisk the little schoolhouse away, townspeople added the anchor in 1937.

Today, a garden with hibiscus, bird-of-paradise, and other tropical plants offer fragrant aromas and soothing shade to the visiting tourists. As part of St. Augustine's history, the Colonial building has also become part of the city's economy.

The St. Augustine schoolhouse is thought to be the oldest wooden school in the United States. Or it might be a simple tourist trap. Should you visit? Read on.

of 04

Why visit old schoolhouses?

Collage of 1-room schoolhouses: red, white, and adobe
Schoolhouses clockwise from top left: Sudbury, MA; Kinderhook, NY; Las Animas County, CO. Photos courtesy Getty Images, clockwise from top left: Richard Berkowitz/Moment Mobile Collection; Barry Winiker/Photolibrary Collection; Carol M. Highsmith/Buyenlarge/Archive Photos Collection

Every year hundreds of children visit the Redstone School, a little red one-room schoolhouse in Sudbury, Massachusetts. Also known as Mary's Little Lamb Schoolhouse, it's said to be the site for the lamb that followed Mary to school one day in that famous nursery rhyme.  However, it's been moved from Sterling, MA and rebuilt from wood that may or may not have been in the original structure. It is a tourist attraction painted red.

The Voorlezer's House—"two-story clapboarded frame building, painted red" and on the records before 1696 in Richmondtown, Staten Island, NY—claims to be "the oldest elementary school building in the United States." Take that, St. Augustine.  But the structure was built also to be a church and a residence, so....

Then there's the Ichabod Crane Schoolhouse in Kinderhook, New York. It, too, is a tourist destination said to be the workplace of the schoolmaster in Washington Irving's fictional story The Legend of Sleepy Hollow. Its architecture is similar to the St. Augustine wooden schoolhouse and Mary's Little Lamb Schoolhouse, except it's painted white.

And then there are the hundreds of abandoned schoolhouses, made of wood, stone, or adobe, like the one shown here in Las Animas County, Colorado. Should we allow these obsolete structures to deteriorate, or should we keep them alive by turning them into picnic areas for tourists?

Schoolhouses around the world are by their very nature historic structures. They trace a community's values, culture, and history. They house memories of common experiences through time. They are part of all of our lives. They hold the stories of America, and some people will do anything to keep the story alive.

Source: The Voorlezer's House, National Register of Historic Places Inventory Nomination Form, prepared by Richard Greenwood, July 17, 1975 (PDF) [accessed June 22, 2016]