The Origins and History of Rice in China and Beyond

The Origins of Rice Domestication in China

Riziéres yunnan
ICHAUVEL / Getty Images

Today, rice (Oryza species) feeds more than half the world's population and accounts for 20 percent of the world's total calorie intake. Although a staple in diets worldwide, rice is central to the economy and landscape of wider East Asian, Southeast Asian, and South Asian ancient and modern civilizations. Particularly in contrast to Mediterranean cultures, which are primarily based on wheat bread, Asian cooking styles, food textural preferences, and feasting rituals are based on consumption of this vital crop.

Rice grows on every continent in the world except Antartica, and has 21 different wild varieties and three distinct cultivated species: Oryza sativa japonica, domesticated in what is today central China by about 7,000 years BC, Oryza sativa indica, domesticated/hybridized in the Indian subcontinent about 2500 BC, and Oryza glabberima, domesticated/hybridized in west Africa between about 1500 and 800 BC.

Earliest Evidence

The oldest evidence of rice consumption identified to date includes four grains of rice recovered from the Yuchanyan Cave, a rock shelter in Dao County, Hunan Province in China. Some scholars associated with the site have argued that these grains seem to represent very early forms of domestication, having characteristics of both japonica and sativa. Culturally, the Yuchanyan site is associated with the Upper Paleolithic/incipient Jomon, dated between 12,000 and 16,000 years ago.

Rice phytoliths (some of which appeared to be identifiable to japonica) were identified in the sediment deposits of Diaotonghuan Cave, located near Poyang Lake in the middle Yangtse river valley radiocarbon dated about 10,000-9000 years before the present. Additional soil core testing of the lake sediments revealed rice phytoliths from rice of some sort present in the valley before 12,820 BP.

However, other scholars argue that although these occurrences of rice grains in archaeological sites such as Yuchanyan and Diaotonghuan caves represent consumption and/or use as pottery temper, they do not represent evidence of domestication.

Origins of Rice in China

Oryza sativa japonica was derived solely from Oryza rufipogon, a poor-yielding rice native to swampy regions that required intentional manipulation of both water and salt, and some harvest experimentation. Just when and where that occurred remains somewhat controversial.

There are four regions that are currently considered possible loci of domestication in China: the middle Yangtze (Pengtoushan culture, including such sites as at Bashidang); the Huai River (including the Jiahu site) of southwest Henan province; the Houli culture of Shandong province; and the lower Yangtze River Valley. Most but not all scholars point to the lower Yangtze River as the likely origin location, which at the end of the Younger Dryas (between 9650 and 5000 BC) was the northern edge of the range for O. rufipogon. Younger Dryas climatic changes in the region included the increase of local temperatures and summer monsoon rainfall amounts, and the inundation of much of the coastal regions of China as the sea rose an estimated 60 meters (~200 feet).

Early evidence for the use of wild O. rufipogon has been identified at Shangshan and Jiahu, both of which contained ceramic vessels tempered with rice chaff, dated between 8000-7000 BC. By about 5,000 BC, domesticated japonica is found throughout the Yangtse valley, including large amounts of rice kernels at such sites as TongZian Luojiajiao (7100 BP) and Hemuda (7000 BP). By 6000-3500 BC, rice and other Neolithic lifestyle changes were spread throughout southern China. Rice reached Southeast Asia into Vietnam and Thailand (Hoabinhian period) by 3000-2000 BC.

The domestication process was likely a gradual one, lasting between 7000 and 4000 BC. Changes from the original plant are recognized as the location of rice fields outside of perennial swamps and wetlands, and non-shattering rachis.

Although scholars have come close to a consensus concerning the origins of rice in China, its subsequent spread outside of the center of domestication in the Yangtze Valley is still a matter of controversy.

Scholars have generally agreed that the originally domesticated plant for all varieties of rice is Oryza sativa japonica, domesticated from O. rufipogon in the lower Yangtze River Valley by hunter-gatherers approximately 9,000 to 10,000 years ago.

Recent research, reported in the journal Rice in December 2011, describes at least 11 separate routes for the spread of rice throughout Asia, Oceania, and Africa. At least twice, say scholars, a manipulation of japonica rice was required: in the Indian subcontinent about 2500 BC, and in West Africa between 1500 and 800 BC.

Possible Domestication

For quite some time, scholars have been divided about the presence of rice in India and Indonesia, where it came from and when it got there. Some scholars have argued that the rice was simply O. japonica, introduced straight from China; others have argued that the O. indica variety of rice is unrelated to japonica and was independently domesticated from Oryza nivara.

Most recently, scholars suggest that Oryza indica is a hybrid between a fully domesticated Oryza japonica and a semi-domesticated or local wild version of Oryza nivara.

Unlike O. japonica, O. nivara can be exploited on a large scale without instituting cultivation or habitat change. The earliest type of rice agriculture used in the Ganges was likely dry cropping, with the plant's water needs provided by monsoonal rains and seasonal flood recession. The earliest irrigated paddy rice in the Ganges is at least the end of the second millennium BC and certainly by the beginning of the Iron Age.

Arrival in the Indus Valley

The archaeological record suggests that O. japonica arrived in the Indus Valley at least as early as 2400-2200 BC, and became well-established in the Ganges River region beginning around 2000 BC. However, by at least 2500 BC, at the site of Senuwar, some rice cultivation, presumably of dryland O. nivara was underway. Additional evidence for the continuing interaction of China by 2000 BC with Northwest India and Pakistan comes from the appearance of other crop introductions from China, including peach, apricot, broomcorn millet, and Cannabis.

 Longshan style harvest knives were made and used in the Kashmir and Swat regions after 2000 BC.

Although Thailand certainly first received domesticated rice from China – archaeological data indicates that until about 300 BC, the dominant type was O. japonica–contact with India about 300 BC, led to the establishment of a rice regime dependent on wetland systems of agriculture, and using O. indica. Wetland rice–that is to say rice grown in flooded paddies–is an invention of Chinese farmers, and so its exploitation in India is of interest.

Rice Paddy Invention

All species of wild rice are wetland species: however, the archaeological record implies that the original domestication of rice was to move it into a more or less dryland environment, planted along the edges of wetlands, and then flooded using natural flooding and annual rain patterns. Wet rice farming, that is to say, including the creation of rice paddies, was invented in China about 5000 BC, with the earliest evidence to date at Tianluoshan, where paddy fields have been identified and dated.

Paddy rice is more labor-intensive then dryland rice, and it requires an organized and stable ownership of land parcels. But it is far more productive than dryland rice, and by creating the stability of terracing and field construction, it reduces environmental damage. In addition, allowing the river to flood the paddies maintains the replacement of nutrients taken from the field by the crop.

Direct evidence for intensive wet rice agriculture, including field systems, comes from two sites in the lower Yangtze (Chuodun and Caoxieshan) both of which date to 4200-3800 BC, and one site (Chengtoushan) in the middle Yangtze at about 4500 BC.

Rice in Africa

A third domestication/hybridization appears to have happened during the African Iron Age in west Africa, by which Oryza sativa was crossed with O. barthii to produce O. glaberrima. The earliest ceramic impressions of rice grains date from between 1800 to 800 BC in the side of Ganjigana, in northeast Nigeria. documented domesticated O. glaberrima has first been identified at Jenne-Jeno in Mali, dated between 300 BC and 200 BC.

Sources

Bellwood P. 2011. The Checkered Prehistory of Rice Movement Southwards as a Domesticated Cereal—from the Yangzi to the EquatorRice 4(3):93-103.

Castillo C. 2011. Rice in Thailand: The Archaeobotanical ContributionRice 4(3):114-120.

d’Alpoim Guedes J. 2011. Millets, Rice, Social Complexity, and the Spread of Agriculture to the Chengdu Plain and Southwest ChinaRice 4(3):104-113.

Fiskesjö M, and Hsing Y-i. 2011. Preface: “Rice and Language Across Asia”Rice 4(3):75-77.

Fuller D. 2011. Pathways to Asian Civilizations: Tracing the Origins and Spread of Rice and Rice CulturesRice 4(3):78-92.

Li Z-M, Zheng X-M, and Ge S. 2011. Genetic diversity and domestication history of African rice (Oryza glaberrima) as inferred from multiple gene sequences. TAG Theoretical and Applied Genetics 123(1):21-31.

Mariotti Lippi M, Gonnelli T, and Pallecchi P. 2011. Rice chaff in ceramics from the archaeological site of Sumhuram (Dhofar, Southern Oman). Journal of Archaeological Science 38(6):1173-1179.

Sagart L. 2011. How Many Independent Rice Vocabularies in Asia? Rice 4(3):121-133.

Sakai H, Ikawa H, Tanaka T, Numa H, Minami H, Fujisawa M, Shibata M, Kurita K, Kikuta A, Hamada M et al. 2011. Distinct evolutionary patterns of Oryza glaberrima deciphered by genome sequencing and comparative analysis. The Plant Journal 66(5):796-805.

Sanchez-Mazas A, Di D, and Riccio M. 2011. A Genetic Focus on the Peopling History of East Asia: Critical Views. Rice 4(3):159-169.

Southworth F. 2011. Rice in DravidianRice 4(3):142-148.

Sweeney M, and McCouch S. 2007. The Complex History of the Domestication of RiceAnnals of Botany 100(5):951-957.

Fiskesjö M, and Hsing Y-i. 2011. Preface: "Rice and Language Across Asia". Rice 4(3):75-77.

Fuller D. 2011. Pathways to Asian Civilizations: Tracing the Origins and Spread of Rice and Rice Cultures. Rice 4(3):78-92.

Hill RD. 2010. The cultivation of perennial rice, an early phase in Southeast Asian agriculture? Journal of Historical Geography 36(2):215-223.

Itzstein-Davey F, Taylor D, Dodson J, Atahan P, and Zheng H. 2007. Wild and domesticated forms of rice (Oryza sp.) in early agriculture at Qingpu, lower Yangtze, China: evidence from phytoliths. Journal of Archaeological Science 34(12):2101-2108.

Jiang L, and Liu L. 2006. New evidence for the origins of sedentism and rice domestication n the Lower Yangzi River, China. Antiquity 80:355-361.

Londo JP, Chiang Y-C, Hung K-H, Chiang T-Y, and Schaal BA. 2006. Phylogeography of Asian wild rice, Oryza rufipogon, reveals multiple independent domestications of cultivated rice, Oryza sativa. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 103(25):9578-9583.

Qin J, Taylor D, Atahan P, Zhang X, Wu G, Dodson J, Zheng H, and Itzstein-Davey F. 2011. Neolithic agriculture, freshwater resources and rapid environmental changes on the lower Yangtze, China. Quaternary Research 75(1):55-65.

Wang W-M, Ding J-L, Shu J-W, and Chen W. 2010. Exploration of early rice farming in China. Quaternary International 227(1):22-28.

Zhang C, and Hung H-c. 2010. The emergence of agriculture in southern China. Antiquity 84:11-25.

Zhang C, and Hung H-c. 2012. Later hunter-gatherers in southern China, 18,000-3000 BC. Antiquity 86(331):11-29.